Analyzing the 49ers’ Week 1 Quarterback Dilemma: Betting Odds for Trey Lance vs. Jimmy G

Will the San Francisco 49ers Trade or Keep Jimmy Garoppolo?

The San Francisco 49ers are facing a pivotal decision regarding their quarterback situation. One of the key questions is whether they will trade their current quarterback, Jimmy Garoppolo, or decide to keep him for the upcoming season. This uncertainty has sparked interest among sports bettors, with BetMGM offering a unique prop bet to predict which quarterback will take the first snap in the first game of the season, Week 1. As of now, rookie Trey Lance is favored to be the starter with -500 odds, while Garoppolo is the underdog with +300 odds.

San Francisco 49ers at Levi’s Stadium

Injury and Rehab:

A key factor in the decision-making process is Jimmy Garoppolo’s recent right shoulder surgery, which will keep him out of action for a couple more months as he undergoes rehabilitation. This injury raises doubts about his immediate readiness for the upcoming season. Given the circumstances, it is highly likely that the 49ers will explore potential trade options for Garoppolo.

Quiet Trade Market:

Despite several notable quarterback trades happening in the offseason, the San Francisco 49ers have been relatively inactive in the trade market. While teams like the Seattle Seahawks and Denver Broncos secured new quarterbacks, the 49ers have refrained from making any major moves. This has led many to speculate that Garoppolo’s future with the team is uncertain.

NFL Prop Bet: Which QB Will Take First Snap for SF 49ers in Week 1?

If you want to test your prediction skills and potentially win a wager, you can place a bet on this intriguing prop bet. In addition to Lance and Garoppolo, there is also an option for “Any Other QB” at +2000 odds. This prop bet not only adds excitement to the upcoming season but also reflects the uncertainty surrounding the 49ers’ quarterback position.

Jimmy G Trade Rumors:

Various trade rumors have circulated in recent months regarding Jimmy Garoppolo’s potential destinations. One strong rumor suggested that the Washington Commanders were interested in acquiring him after failing to secure Russell Wilson in a trade with the Seattle Seahawks. However, their attempt was rejected, and the Seattle Seahawks eventually traded Wilson to the Denver Broncos.

Another team mentioned in trade rumors was the Indianapolis Colts, but they ended up making a deal for Matt Ryan from the Atlanta Falcons. It is unclear whether the lack of trade activity was due to teams being cautious about Garoppolo’s recovery timeline or if the 49ers simply value him highly and are not in a hurry to part ways.

Coach’s Perspective:

San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan acknowledged the uncertainty surrounding Garoppolo’s future but emphasized the team’s intentions to make the best decision for their overall success. Shanahan recognized the importance of Jimmy G’s surgery and its impact on potential trade offers. He stated, “We’re not just getting rid of him to get rid of him. We have to wait until people feel good about that surgery.”

Shanahan also highlighted the value of having multiple capable quarterbacks on the roster, stating, “Quarterbacks are really hard to come by. Some teams don’t have any, and we have three that we’re happy with, which is a good thing.” This perspective suggests that the 49ers may choose to keep Garoppolo as an insurance policy and wait for the right opportunity to make a trade.

Lance: Starting Sooner or Later

The 49ers made a bold move in the 2021 NFL Draft by trading up to select Trey Lance as the third overall pick. This decision demonstrated their belief that Lance has the potential to become their next franchise quarterback. However, the team took a different approach than many expected, choosing to hold Lance back initially and allow him to acclimate to the NFL gradually.

Shanahan’s rationale for this approach was twofold. Firstly, Garoppolo’s presence as a capable starter allowed the 49ers to give Lance more time to develop without immediate pressure. Secondly, it speaks to Jimmy G’s character that he eagerly embraced his role as a mentor to the young rookie quarterback, rather than displaying any resentment. This positive dynamic within the team bodes well for their future success.

In his limited appearances as a starter, Trey Lance showcased glimpses of his potential. He demonstrated his arm strength, completing 41 passes for 603 yards, with five touchdowns and two interceptions. Additionally, he showcased his mobility by rushing for 168 yards and one touchdown on 38 carries.

Considering Shanahan’s recent comments, it seems highly likely that Trey Lance will be the starting quarterback in Week 1. With this expectation, Jimmy Garoppolo finds himself as the underdog in the prop bet for the 49ers’ first game of the season.


The San Francisco 49ers currently face the dilemma of whether to trade Jimmy Garoppolo or keep him as their starting quarterback for the upcoming season. While Garoppolo’s shoulder surgery and recovery timeline raise concerns, the 49ers have not actively pursued trade opportunities. Head coach Kyle Shanahan values the depth and talent of their current quarterback roster and emphasizes making the best decision for the team’s success.

Meanwhile, rookie Trey Lance patiently awaits his opportunity to take over as the starting quarterback. His potential and the positive team dynamics surrounding his development make him an enticing prospect. As fans eagerly anticipate Week 1, the prop bet on the 49ers’ first snap will provide an extra layer of excitement. Only time will tell which quarterback will ultimately lead the San Francisco 49ers.


1. What are the odds for Trey Lance starting in Week 1?

As of now, Trey Lance is the favorite to take the first snap in Week 1, with -500 odds.

2. Is Jimmy Garoppolo expected to be traded?

While numerous trade rumors have circulated, the San Francisco 49ers have not yet made a move to trade Jimmy Garoppolo. The uncertainty surrounding his future remains.

3. What factors influenced the 49ers’ decision to select Trey Lance?

The 49ers traded up in the 2021 NFL Draft to select Trey Lance because they saw him as their potential franchise quarterback. They valued his talent, arm strength, mobility, and leadership qualities.

4. Will Jimmy Garoppolo’s injury impact his trade value?

Garoppolo’s recent shoulder surgery and recovery timeline may influence potential trade offers. Teams may be cautious about acquiring him until he fully recovers and proves his fitness.

5. How does the prop bet on the first snap impact the 49ers’ season?

The prop bet adds an extra layer of excitement and intrigue to the start of the 49ers’ season. It reflects the uncertainty surrounding their quarterback situation and allows fans to engage in the speculation themselves.

Doug I. Jones

Doug I. Jones

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, cons the all tetur adiscing elit